THOM CALANDRA'S STOCKWATCH - Energy market set for tumble. Dose of reality as investors ignore political drama
cbs.marketwatch.com By Thom Calandra, CBS.MarketWatch.com Last Update: 1:22 PM ET Feb. 25, 2003
SAN FRANCISCO (CBS.MW) - Energy investors will face a jolt of reality if Iraqi leader Saddam Hussein sidesteps a looming physical assault on his nation, says a financial author and money manager.
CBS MARKETWATCH COMMENTARY
THOM CALANDRA (WEEKDAYS) Ignoring political news, energy markets set to tumble TOMI KILGORE (MONDAYS) A lack of volume is negating some positive signals BAMBI FRANCISCO (TUESDAYS) Why Ma Bell should buy Covad MIKE TARSALA (WEDNESDAYS) The tech guidebooks are all wrong DAVID CALLAWAY (THURSDAYS) Osama and the great duct tape conspiracy JON FRIEDMAN (FRIDAYS) What am I offered for CNN?
"If indeed Saddam does capitulate, this is the major story that most of the Western media are missing," says Joseph A. Duarte, author of "Successful Energy Investing" and president of River Willow Capital Management in Dallas.
Duarte was watching energy futures and other market bellwethers from his snowed-in Dallas office Tuesday. Natural gas futures alone were rising 10 percent in early trading, then losing that gain and falling another 10 percent, all this after a 38 percent gain Monday. The Dow Jones Transportation Index (26099605: news, chart, profile) Tuesday morning was falling 1.5 percent, taking the key industrial barometer below 2,000 for the first time since September 1996.
Duarte also uses shares of energy companies Lone Star Technologies (LSS: news, chart, profile) and Apache Corp. (APA: news, chart, profile) as ciphers on the geopolitical landscape. Both, like energy futures, are up sharply since the start of the year, with Lone Star logging a 35 percent gain. "Both have predictive abilities in terms of the energy futures," says Duarte, who is also a practicing medical doctor and anesthesiologist.
Duarte says many investors, especially those looking for continued gains in the stratospheric crude-oil market, will require anesthesia in coming hours or days because they are deducing simplistic probabilities from the Iraq situation. He relies on several little-known news outlets to form a thesis that soaring energy markets may soon crash.
One of those news outlets, subscription service Strategic Forecasting, is run out of Austin, Texas, and goes by the name Stratfor.com. George Friedman, a former Director of the Center for Geopolitical Studies at Louisiana State University, started the service in 1996.
"Iraq exports 1.7 million barrels of oil a day," Friedman explained to me Tuesday morning. "In the event of a total catastrophic war, the world markets will lose just 1.7 million gallons at a time when Venezuela oil is coming back online and many producers, like Saudi Arabia, want to fill that capacity. The rising oil market is acting how it always does in the short term, irrationally."
Strategic Forecasting's reports on the evolving influence of France, Germany and Russia in the Iraq conflict are getting almost no attention from U.S. newspapers and broadcasters. One article, published late last week, describes a nearly three-decade personal relationship between French President Jacques Chirac and Saddam Hussein.
In late 1974, then-French Premier Chirac traveled to Baghdad and met then-Vice President Saddam Hussein. "In September 1975, Hussein traveled to Paris, where Chirac personally gave him a tour of a French nuclear plant," said the article. France later sold two reactors to Iraq - "in other words, enough weapons-grade uranium to produce three to four nuclear devices."
Duarte also monitors The Moscow Times for reports about Germany and Russia. He says, "There has been documented evidence of correspondence between Saddam and Chirac over the years and the French government has not denied there have been personal letters."
Duarte, who gets credit for being among the first, along with Friedman's Stratfor.com, to recognize the political problems that shut down Venezuela's oil industry late last year, says several political figures face their greatest challenges in the next several weeks.
The money manager points to reports, ignored in the American press, that the German government admitted holding back evidence of smallpox-virus arsenals in Iraq. The news organization Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung says German authorities may have been worried that news of the arsenals would ruin Chancellor Gerhardt Schroeder's re-election effort.
Schroeder on Wednesday will visit Moscow at the invitation of Russian President Vladimir Putin. The Russian leader this past weekend sent a former prime minister, Yevgeny Primakov, to meet with Saddam in Baghdad. Stratfor describes Primakov as a friend of Saddam.
Duarte in the past 18 months has forecast accurately the growing volatility of energy markets. He also has laid out the growing importance of Russia and the diminishing influence of the Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries on supply and demand in the oil marketplace.
"Look, Saddam does have smallpox, the virus, and it is a biological weapon, and Germany knows about it," he says. "As these things start coming out in the open, and Putin gets involved, a lot of personal things that can be politically damaging will shape events. Over the last two or three days a lot of reports have come out that are damning to a lot of people."
France, Germany and Russia have submitted a proposal to the United Nations calling for a step-by-step disarmament of Iraq. At the same time, intelligence reports, according to Duarte, suggest Russia's Putin may be preparing an Iraq message to U.S. and British oil companies, inviting the multinationals back into the oil-producing country.
Duarte says it is in the interests of several world leaders to promote a peaceful resolution to the Iraq crisis. "If we don't see a solution, then a lot of things are going to unravel for a lot of people. Political futures are being shaped here for Putin, Chirac, Schroeder and President Bush. This is like the Winston Churchill stage of World War II. It is no longer just about war, it is about the people, and this is when things start to happen."
Duarte sees some signs that energy markets may be "topping out." He says the futures prices of heating oil, crude oil, gasoline and natural gas have been "parabolic, and they can't keep going straight up, regardless of a war or a cold winter." One anecdotal sign a plateau is near for energy futures come from the bold statements of Devon Energy 's (DVN: news, chart, profile) chairman and chief executive, J. Larry Nichols. He said in a conference call that natural gas prices will be "permanently" higher.
"We've permanently moved into a new era of gas prices," Nichols said Monday. Natural gas futures on the New York Mercantile Exchange Tuesday were selling for as much as high as $8.63 per one million British thermal units. Devon, seizing the day, says it will buy Ocean Energy for about $3.5 billion worth of common stock.
For those who don't follow energy markets, such bold statements and actions are something like Internet giant Yahoo buying Geocities, a multi-billion purchase that happened during the hysteria that surrounded the growing use of online services and the World Wide Web in the late 1990s. On the energy scene, the Devon purchase would make the Oklahoma company the largest independent producer of oil and natural gas on American shores.
"Whenever anyone says something is headed permanently higher, smart investors should be looking over their shoulder," says Duarte. "Everyone is talking about yesterday's news, but I think it may pay to start thinking about what happens when the futures prices crumble."
In that event, shares of energy beneficiary Apache, a Houston company that is near an all-time price high, easily could lose 15 percent to 25 percent of their value in a short span.
Coming Wednesday: An interview with Stratfor.com's George Friedman.
Thom Calandra's StockWatch newsletter
You can get free delivery of Thom Calandra's StockWatch every trading day. Sign up for Thom Calandra's StockWatch newsletter at CBS MarketWatch. Coming soon: The Calandra Report, a subscription service for Alert Investors. Brought to you by CBS MarketWatch.