At the UN: Concentric circles grow--Proposal to link north, south Native nations and populations
by L.A. Shively INDIAN COUNTRY TODAY
ALBUQUERQUE, N.M., May 21 — The United Nations Permanent Forum on Indigenous Peoples concluded its activities this week with a flurry of reports and announcements. By all accounts it was an exhilarating second annual session. ‘If we can stimulate our products, the other problems, such as health and education, will improve as well. It follows that those problems will be solved if we are stronger economically. It follows.’ — JEREMY ATKINSON Arawak delegate from Guayana region of Venezuela TO THE INTERNATIONAL indigenous delegates: best of wishes for the journey home. Congratulations on a wonderful 12 days of dialogue and activities - focused on the theme of creating a positive future for indigenous peoples.
Words are important. Self-representation is crucial. At the United Nations, for all its beleaguered status, representatives of many governments took notice and heard serious reports on the global condition of the Native peoples. Noeli Pocaterra, Wayuu elder and parliamentary leader from Venezuela, reminded us of words from Ingrid Washinawatok, when she quoted: “The silence must be broken.”
Noeli was among the many wonderful Native leaders from around the world who gathered in New York. Quechua and Aymara from Bolivia, Peru, Ecuador, Mapuche from Chile, Amazonian peoples from several countries, Arawak from Venezuela, Massai from Kenya, Sami from Norway, Dene from Canada and many others among the core of the indigenous representatives and intellectuals active on matters of international law and international development attended. SEEING LOST RELATIVES
It was refreshing to see long lost relatives - among the South American Arawak and the Caribbean Taino, for instance - meet and greet each other, embrace and begin longed-for conversations. It was good to see veteran battlers like the Mapuche activist, Nilo Cayuqueo, who was there at the very beginning of the international struggle. Cayuqueo described the economic collapse in his native Argentina, where even the upper middle class is looting food stores as evidence of severe desperation, so, he said, “imagine the misery and desperation of the Indian people.” Nilo is a Native universalist spirit who traveled the hemisphere in the late 1960s, as the nascent Indian movement began its cross-country outreach. He is perhaps among four others of the 1,500 in attendance who participated in the seminal event of the international movement, the Geneva Indigenous Peoples Conference of 1977.
• Indian Country Today front Twenty-five years later, in the long, cold halls of the UN, Nilo introduced us to several tribal people from Colombia, focusing our editorial eye once again on the major heartbreak of that country’s gut-tearing, horrifically bloody “violencia” that has become social habit and entrenched mechanism - war without end. One story to pass on: the Embera Indian leadership in Colombia is being assassinated with impunity. FARC, the spirit-dead revolutionary movement, stands denounced; so does the widespread right-wing para-military violence, very often linked with the military. The silence was broken many times at the UN gathering. Important stories and viewpoints were told.
Indian Country Today prepared a special edition for the event. One of our themes proposed stronger and more profound cultural and economic linkages between northern and southern Native nations and populations. We concur with the words of Jeremy Atkinson, a young Arawak delegate from the Guayana region of Venezuela, who put it this way: “We have resources, we have our people. From our lands and waters and from our own hands, we can improve our economics, grow our business practice. If we can stimulate our products, the other problems, such as health and education, will improve as well. It follows that those problems will be solved if we are stronger economically. It follows.” ECONOMIC OPTION
As with the strengthening of human rights initiatives, Native peoples need to explore economic options wherever they can find them. This is a current that does not please everyone, but it is the nugget of the fundamental solution to most of our peoples’ problems. Self-generated economies, wherever they can be stimulated, will provide the rotors of future self-determined Native peoples.
The Indian unity which is sought has always been elusive. Native nations are just as good at competing with each other as they are in confronting the state and federal entities and the occasional ugly head of white supremacy that surrounds them. Furthermore, each is unique, facing very localized as well as national challenges. International development efforts, whether through foundations, the World Bank or now through Native nation-to-nation trade and commerce, is best served by great attention to local dynamics and conditions.
In the language employed to codify the rights of the indigenous peoples of the world, the broad-brush stroke is the genial half. But for answering questions of developmental impact - how a community betters itself economically and culturally and socially, how income is generated so families, tribal businesses and communities are able to expand themselves - understanding and incorporating the locally specific is key. Canada is not Venezuela and the Caribbean is not the Andes and even the U.S. situation of Indians varies greatly between Montana and the Southwest or the East Coast from South Dakota and California.
Unity in diversity is a good indigenous definition. From small to big - being part of something larger that gathers one’s concerns and issues is as important as ever. Exertion of power beyond the small group, reaching beyond one community, to the regional and the national, to the international, this is important. BUILDING BONDS
The Native world could well benefit from a substantial initiative of cooperative and sustained relations across the hemispheres. All Native students, all Native children, should know that they are part of something substantially large. All Native youth should have the chance to know the intimate intents of the ancient and contemporary ideas of their peoples. They should know that they are part of something that is hemispherically, even globally, strong.
There is an indigenous base of culture that values the kinship community. Families are large, extended, and as they overlap, the linkages of origin, from both matriarchs and patriarchs, reveal themselves. The core indigenous peoples’ experience of community life revolves around this principle and extends out from it - when it is strong and true - to the ever-larger concentric circles of relationships that form the families, clans, nations and populations of the Native world. In today’s world these overlap with the myriad federations and confederations, national organizations, international organizations, governmental coalitions, national and international cultural pilgrimages, circles and journeys, via ceremonial life, pow wows, business, legal cases and the many other ways that indigenous peoples coalesce with each other.
The Native leadership of any community today that would utilize its best resources to ensure the future survival of its people should seriously generate cultural and economic and political relations with other Native peoples. The cohesive and common experience is crucial to building toward the future and the search for strength in common is more important than ever.
The submarine behaves as the Titanic
LUISA AMELIA MARACARA EL UNIVERSAL
Venezuelan Planning Minister Jorge Giordani has never been more accurate than when branding the Gross Domestic Product as a submarine, since it behaves as such.
As a matter of fact, Venezuela's GDP sunk so many meters last year that the contraction reached 8.9 percent. In 2001, it had an insignificant growth, 2.8 percent; in 2000, the figure was 3.2 percent. Those two years did not compensate the 6.1 percent fall registered in 1999.
The submarine that Giordani referred to seems to be involved in a campaign that maintains it in the deepest waters, where pressure is so intense that is shattering it. This is reflected in the initial estimates by the Venezuelan Central Bank, which point to a 35 percent fall in the first quarter.
Actions adopted by the government so far this year do not seem to be intended to refrain the submarine from sinking. In fact, it has been showing many similarities to Titanic, which broke into two pieces, sank and never surfaced again. As the economy takes in water, the government's announcements to reactivate general production have not yielded any good results.
Each month, at least one minister announce a plan to reactivate his/her sector. But positive results do not come. In fact, President Hugo Chávez himself has admitted in the latest editions of his weekly radio and TV show ¡Aló, Presidente! the failure of many of their plans; he even complains about the State's functioning.
Meanwhile, the captain of the submarine, since his recent designation as Planning Minister, has chosen to remain in silence. He may be thinking on a new name to describe the behavior of the economy.
OAS General Secretary Cesar Gaviria puts out feelers to test political will to reach agreement
<a href=www.vheadline.com>venezuela's Electronic News Posted: Wednesday, May 21, 2003 By: Patrick J. O'Donoghue
Organization of American States (OAS) general secretary, Cesar Gaviria has made a stopover in Venezuela to try and put wind in the sails of government-opposition negotiations, which once again have stalled.
Gaviria has been meeting representatives of both sides separately to find out if there is enough political will to continue sessions and seek an electoral, pacific and constitutional solution.
The crunch point is whether the opposition will reply to the government's counter-proposal to a pre-agreement document, which the opposition expected the government to sign and which the government agreed to discuss among its allies before returning to the table.
The opposition has encountered difficulties in its own camp from critics who say opposition negotiators should have dealt with the counter-proposal then and there to get the recall referendum rolling instead of wasting time.
OAS representative in Caracas, Fernando Jaramillo has prepared a new document which could be the starting-point for further negotiations and is limited to electoral aspects.
Opposition negotiators, Alejandro Armas and Rafael Alfonso say they are ready to continue negotiations and Executive Vice President Jose Vicente Rangel has made it clear on several occasions that the government is open, declaring that the ball is in the opposition's court.
Gaviria is expected to leave Venezuela for Argentina and Peru and could return next Monday to continue his job as facilitator.
After wrapping up exploratory meetings with the opposition and Vice President Jose Vicente Rangel, Carter Center representatives, Jennifer McCoy and Francisco Diez confirm that they are confident there will be an agreement.
The two representatives contend that Rangel has ratified the government's disposition to reach an agreement and support for the Carter Center's continuing role as facilitator and observer in Venezuela.
Opposition bench rejects AN statement against US Ambassador Charles Shapiro's undiplomatic antics
<a href=www.vheadline.com>venezuela's Electronic News Posted: Wednesday, May 21, 2003 By: Patrick J. O'Donoghue
Christian Socialist (COPEI) National Assemblyman Cesar Perez Vivas has hit out at a proposal from Movimiento Quinta Republica (MVR) deputy Tarek William Saab to condemn US Ambassador Charles Shapiro for his silly World Press Freedom Day show.
Perez Vivas says the proposal, which was approved in a Tuesday sitting, does not represent the totality of Parliament.
"Saab should have presented the motion as a MVR proposal and not as the proposal of a plural Assembly, in which there are different perspectives on the matter."
Most of the opposition preferred not to support Saab's proposal, alleging that the government was using the incident as a smokescreen for the real problems facing Venezuela.
Other critics complain that Saab's motion was rejected because it was not worded as a reaction to an insult to all Venezuelans but as a defense of the Chavez Frias administration.
Going back down memory lane, if the Chavists in opposition had opposed such a motion, they would have been stigmatized "anti-patriotic." Deputy Perez Vivas is not reported as explaining his take on the US Embassy incident.
Venezuelan President Hugo Chavez Frias admits hopeless media exposure of government achievements
<a href=www.vheadline.com>Venezuela's Electronic news Posted: Wednesday, May 21, 2003 By: Patrick J. O'Donoghue
Venezuelan President Hugo Chavez Frias says 2002 could have been the first year of a civil war and that violence was avoided because the government decided to open a dialog process, despite opposition pressure.
"After the coup attempt we did not fall into provocations and instead convoked a dialog ... it would have been a mistake to initiate a drive against the coupsters and to have adopted a tough stance ... it would have led to further violence."
Speaking during the inauguration of extension work on Caracas Metro Line 3 , the President states that the government is learning to co-exist in democracy, insisting that he does not want to see another year like 2002 and the way forward is to change attitudes and seek conciliation in the interest of all sectors of society.
In a moment of self-criticism, Chavez Frias admits that his government has been poor in its efforts to communicate what it has been doing ... "very bad ... people are unaware of the public works that are being built, including the underground railroad extensions in Caracas, Los Teques, Maracaibo and Valencia."
According to the President, some impartial foreign media experts undertook a study and told him that the opposition has a 500% media surplus compared to what is normal in other countries that have a critical opposition ... "opposition is normal in democracy ... they also said the government's media deficit stands at 85%."
Chavez Frias has promised to continue seeking a solution but says it's like a counter-culture or a force holding the government back.
The Cabinet comes under fire for not letting the country know about the government's social works in view of the fact that there is no country in Latin America that is building the number of works as Venezuela.